South Africa pulls draft AI policy after fake citations slipped in

Why the process failure matters more than the headline

When governments rush to write AI rules, the documents themselves become a test of whether basic oversight is working. ReutersTech’s April 27 post compressed that into three sharp words: "fake AI-generated sources". South Africa’s first draft national AI policy was pulled because the reference list included fictitious citations that appeared to have been generated by AI. Once the sourcing breaks, the policy’s broader ambitions stop mattering until trust is rebuilt.

"fake AI-generated sources"

The ReutersTech account usually serves as a headline wire into fuller reporting, and that is what happened here. The linked Reuters report says South Africa withdrew the draft after the bogus references were discovered. Communications and Digital Technologies Minister Solly Malatsi said the most plausible explanation was that AI-generated citations had been included without proper verification, and he said there would be consequences for those responsible. That turns the story from a generic embarrassment into a governance case study: the same class of tools being regulated appears to have contaminated the policy drafting process itself.

The substance of the draft makes the withdrawal more consequential. Reuters says the policy sought to position South Africa as a continental AI leader while creating a National AI Commission, an AI Ethics Board, and an AI Regulatory Authority. It also outlined incentives such as tax breaks, grants, and subsidies to encourage private-sector collaboration. In other words, this was not a placeholder memo. It was a real framework with at least three proposed institutions and a concrete economic agenda behind it.

What to watch next is not just when a replacement draft appears, but how the government rewires verification and accountability around it. Other ministries and regulators are also experimenting with generative AI in drafting and research workflows. That means this episode could ripple well beyond South Africa, especially if it pushes public institutions to formalize citation checks and human review before policy documents go out for comment. Source: ReutersTech source tweet · Reuters report