Ashes of Creation Funding Dispute Escalates After New Ledger-Based Allegations

What happened

Kotaku reported on April 12, 2026 that new allegations have widened the public and legal dispute around Ashes of Creation, the now-defunct MMORPG from Intrepid Studios that raised $3.2 million on Kickstarter. The latest round came after a detailed April 11 video from YouTube channel NefasQS, which said it had obtained and processed Intrepid Studios’ general ledger from 2015 to 2026.

According to Kotaku’s summary of that material, the allegations point to spending that critics say looks personal rather than project-related. The examples cited in the report include payments to a personal chef, auction sites for historical curios, a luxury cigar retailer, trading card and miniature stores, and $81,166 to Gore Oil, which Kotaku says was tied to the deed history of a San Diego home connected to former CEO Steven Sharif and John Moore.

Response and uncertainty

Kotaku also published Sharif’s response. He said the spreadsheet and the related reporting are false or defamatory, denied any misuse of Kickstarter money, and argued the dispute should be resolved through the federal court case that is already underway rather than through social media or YouTube. That distinction matters because none of these new allegations amount to a court finding. At this stage, the story remains a contested fight between former leadership, the board, and outside critics.

Why it matters

The broader significance is less about one expense item and more about what it says about trust in crowdfunded MMO development. Ashes of Creation was already under pressure after its Steam removal in February, and the earlier collapse of studio operations had already made the project a cautionary case. Fresh ledger-based claims keep the project in the spotlight and raise the stakes for everyone involved, because backers, former employees, and potential partners are all watching how accountability is handled.

For the wider market, the case is another reminder that community-funded projects live or die on transparency. Even when claims remain disputed, public confidence can erode quickly once financial governance becomes part of the headline. Source: Kotaku, April 12, 2026, with Sharif’s statement included in the report.